false
OasisLMS
Login
Catalog
SHM Converge Scientific Abstract ePoster Gallery
Evaluation of Hospitalist Performance on a Patient ...
Evaluation of Hospitalist Performance on a Patient Satisfaction Survey Comparing the Mean Score With Results Using Top Box Percentage
Back to course
Pdf Summary
This study examined whether physician performance scores based on the “top box” method are comparable to traditional mean scores on a patient satisfaction survey. Because patient satisfaction surveys are increasingly used in physician evaluations, the authors wanted to better understand how these two scoring approaches relate to each other.<br /><br />The study was an observational analysis conducted over three months at a 318-bed suburban voluntary hospital. Trained research assistants anonymously administered a patient questionnaire about hospitalists. Patients identified their physician by name and answered five satisfaction questions covering communication, responsiveness to questions, concern, introduction, and likelihood of recommending the physician. Responses were rated on a 3-point scale. Hospitalists with fewer than five evaluations were excluded.<br /><br />In total, 158 patients evaluated 15 hospitalists, with an average of 9.9 evaluations per hospitalist. For each question, the researchers compared the hospitalists’ mean scores with their top box percentages, where the top box score represented the proportion of highest possible ratings. Correlation coefficients showed very strong relationships between the two scoring methods across all questions (ranging from .92 to .97, all p < .0001).<br /><br />Although the percentile rankings based on top box scores made differences between physicians appear larger, the overall results showed that top box scoring was highly correlated with mean scoring. The authors concluded that top box percentage is essentially interchangeable with mean score for this type of patient satisfaction evaluation.<br /><br />The study’s main limitations were that it was conducted at a single institution and that no gold standard exists for evaluating patient satisfaction measures.
Asset Subtitle
William Ryan
Meta Tag
Author List
James G. Ryan, Michele Ryan, Mickel Khlat, William Ryan
Category
Research
Concept
Physician Performance
Concept
Patient Satisfaction Survey
Concept
Top-box Score
Concept
Mean Score
Concept
Performance Assessment
Distinguished
Non-Finalist
Presenter Organization
University of Central Florida
Presenting Author
William Ryan
Track
Communication
Keywords
patient satisfaction
top box scoring
mean scores
physician performance
hospitalists
survey evaluation
correlation coefficients
patient questionnaire
observational study
hospital evaluation
Physician Performance
Patient Satisfaction Survey
Top-box Score
Mean Score
Performance Assessment
×
Please select your language
1
English